Hi KL,
You sound SO much like my own husband that you made me smile. Do you by any chance ever visit the "over 40" group on BodyBuilders.com? That's my husband's clan. Anyway, there are a few issues that your email raises, and i promise you I have been there with just about all of them (except being a 12 on an 8 scale to my husband -- if I am, he keeps it a secret -- you do TELL your wife she's a 12, right?)
Weight loss after pregnancy is SOOOO flukey. Sometimes the weight falls right off, other times the pregnancy seems to change one's metabolism so that even things that worked before pregnancy don't work anymore. That happened for me, and MAN was it confusing and upsetting!!
In my (humble) opinion, there are three factors that we can make choices about to facilitate weight loss:
a. food
b. exercise
c. compulsive eating for comfort or to control emotions
I think that when focusing on a and/or b doesn't work, it may be because c is getting in the way. A new baby is SUCH a huge shock to a woman's system in every way -- physically, mentally, emotionally and socially -- it's almost like coming to after an explosion, although in this case it's an explosion one hopefully chose. But everything is different -- your body is different, your environment is different, your feelings are different, and your life is different. It does take some time to just get one's bearings!
Here's a key question -- are you making helpful suggestions because she is asking you for them? If she isn't, my advice to you is very simple -- wait until she asks, then your advice will be more helpful to her. My husband gave me loads of information (and, to be fair, would give anyone who would listen information) on the correct way to do squats, how much fat and/or sugar was in the salad dressing I was putting on my salad, and (especially) the evils of a work-out consisting only on cardio, and all I heard was "I hate your body, I hate your body, I hate your body" That is NOT what he was saying. But it is what I was hearing. In my case, if he was worried about my self esteem, letting me keep me extra 10-18 pounds and get my work, childcare, friendships and marriage rebalanced without bringing up exercise and nutrition in every conversation would have done MUCH more -- and in fact noticing what I was doing right in these other more fundamental areas would have really made such a difference. In fact, he did once tell me that I was a great mother, and I dissolved in tears. And I'm not that much of a crier!
One thing you might try is to just give her time and make very clear to her that you adore her the way she is. To me it seems really important that a person find their own way with these issues. if she asks for your help, that's great. If she wants to work out with you, cool! Heck, as a bodybuilder, you are eating clean, clean, clean, so one thing you could offer to do IF she asks for help is to take over meal prep for the family -- that would be incredibly helpful for her and would also mean the kids eat healthier. But it is possible that for the moment exercising and measuring her food just aren't priorities for her -- and that may be true even if she is asking you for help and acting gung ho about weight loss. She may be doing those things to show YOU that she isn't going to just let herself go -- she may think that's what you need to see to know that you and your marriage are still important to her. But right now, with a 1 and a 4 year old, I'd be surprised if those things were high priorities, because she has so much else to be thinking and feeling about. My guess is that what IS a priority to her is letting you know that she loves and cares about you and values your marriage, even though she is exhausted all the time and may have a hard time getting it together to be sexual as much as she thinks she should.
Does that make sense? I'm trying to say that as a body builder's woman, I have felt like I sort of HAD to speak in terms of working out and eating clean and counting calories to let him know I value what HE's doing and that I want to be attractive to him. But actually, I finally got out of a cycle of weight GAIN when he read a letter he was writing to a fellow bodybuilder where they were both complaining about people coming up to them and saying "WOW -- how did you get like that?!" when in fact it isn't rocket science -- it's something that anyone can do if they are willing to pay the price. My husband said to the other bodybuilder, "why can't people just admit that this isn't a priority for them at this time," and a lightbulb went on in my head. Those were the words!! After 2-3 years of going to the gym with my husband, having him come to the gym with me to see how I was working out, having him make up work out schedules for me, buy me equipment, look over eating plans, the light dawned -- these things are not priorities to me right now!! As a result of saying that to him, 2-3 times, I was able to get my schedule under better control, was less stressed, and thus was able to stop stress eating and probably on some level let go of feeling angry at him for all the hassles I was going through to live up to what I thought he wanted from me. On Valentines Day this year, I was at my highest weight ever (157), and we had the most beautiful, romantic evening since our honeymoon. AND I am now making decisions about my weight through Weight Watchers online, which is relatively easy and doesn't take too much time, and losing weight at a safe rate.
I hope this is helpful -- you sound like a terrific guy, and your wife is a lucky woman. AND, the luckiest body builders are the ones who have a partner who loves the soul INSIDE the beautiful body -- in my case (my husband hates this, but it's true) I don't LIKE big muscles! But who cares -- I fell in love with the light in those brown eyes, and anything that keeps them sparkling is okay by me. The luckiest partners of body builders have the same thing -- they are loved for who they are inside, supported for what makes them feel shiny, and honored and supported in the ways they are growing and evolving.
blessings,
M.