You don't like the reviews of doctors you've researched because you don't want to drug him? Whether or not he needs drugs is way down the line. A doctor will not immediately put him on drugs and he won't put him on drugs at all unless you agree to do so.
I suggest, it's imperative that you pick a doctor, make an appointment for just you and your husband to talk with him to see if you could work with him. The psychiatrist will then spend time with all of you individually and together to find a diagnosis and make a treatment plan.
Diagnosis and treatment is not a 1 or 3 appointment process. It will take time and several appointments before the psychiatrist will have an idea about what his problem involves and then it will still be limited. Having a mental illness is not like having the flu or appendicitis. Diagnosis and then treatment takes time and intense involvement.
I have mental health intervention training and experience as a law enforcement officer assigned to a specialized group. This does sound like mental illness and will continue to get worse without intervention.
The military will not accept him. They are not geared to handle mental illness or even out of control behavior. You can call a recruiter and ask about this but please be honest with them. A dishonorable discharge for angry outbursts and uncontrolled behavior is not what he needs.
After your addition: It's hard to get started and it sounds like you're at that point. I suggest that you get started by making the first decision. Don't try to look at everything at once. The most important thing to do is to get started with a psychiatrist. Just get started. Pick one, out of the phone book, if necessary and make an appointment. Try that one out with just you and your husband. If you're not satisfied with his philosphy and method of treatment then call a different one. Write out a list of questions you want to ask. You have a start with the things you didn't like about the other ones. Turn those criticisms into a list of what you do want.
Also, know that you won't really know what a doctor is like until you talk with him yourself. I don't understand what you mean by reviews. Do you know the people writing the reviews? If not, you don't know how what they say would apply to you and your situation. If a friend or pastor has recommended them, try them out to see how they fit with you.
It's important to take that first step. Yes, he needs a psychiatrist. A psychotherapist is usually a psychiatrist. Both can prescribe medications. However, you're not at the point of knowing he needs medication. You need to first have a diagnosis and a psychiatrist makes a diagnosis. Other professionals aren't as qualified to make diagnosis when the condition is a mental illness.
Take this one step at a time. Get a diagnosis. If he needs more than what the psychiatrist can provide he will include others in your son's treatment. It may be that your son will need something different thanwhat the psychiatrist does and he will recommend that too. It doesn't mean you'll have to start over with someone new.
I suggest that you're not familiar with the system and are understandably anxious. I urge you to just get started. Make an appointment. Take it one step at a time. The longer you wait, the more confused you'll be and the more difficulties you and your son will have.
Make that call this week. Make a list of the psychiatrists who have been recommended by knowledgable friends and the pastor. Put the names of ones who've provided actual treatment for your friends at the top of the list. Do not consider anyone who is not a psychiatrist. It's essential that you get an accurate diagnosis if he has a psychiatric disorder and only a psychiatrist can do that.
Or call for a referral from a medical association. Look in the yellow pages. Just choose one and go. Ask your questions. Ask for them to explain the system of mental health care to you. Gain a better understanding of not only what you're dealing with but also of whether or not this person seems reasonable and effective in their approach with you.
As the saying goes, "Just Do It." You've already delayed too long in seeking understanding and treatment for your son. Make an appointment this week and get started.
I am a real life mother who has been in similar tho perhaps less serious situations both personally and more serious issues professionally. I've been in psychotherapy with a psychiatrist for neurotic and self learning issues. I have a daughter who has been in therapy for serious mental health issues. And I was trained as a law enforcement officer to be a part of a team that addressed mental health issues in the community.
I know it's difficult to know what to do. I've experienced that feeling many times. I'm there now with my cousin's will. I've learned that when I take just the first step gradually everything falls into place. The path will not be smooth or easy. There will be bumps and detours along the way. Doing nothing does not work. Take that first step.