Bedtime Routine - Hockessin,DE

Updated on August 22, 2012
C.R. asks from Hockessin, DE
9 answers

my dd is 19mos old. she doesn't sleep through the night yet. she does maybe once if lucky 2x a week. when she cries, my husband runs in to get her, change her, and rocks her to sleep again. i would like to let her cry a bit so she learns to soothe herself back to sleep. he won't do that. how can i get him to understand that she needs to learn this behavior. it is best for her sleep patterns and ours. at nap time, i read to her, and lay her in her crib. she fusses a bit and is asleep in less than 15 minutes.
thank you for your advice!

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

So What Happened?

thank you all for your responses. i really appreciate it! unfortunatley, he thinks he is doing nothing wrong. it is his time with her. i suppose. he rocks her to sleep at bedtime and falls alseep with her for hours in the glider then comes to bed. he does this several times a week. i put our 6 year old to bed and we take turns. i think this is an issue. he just argues with me. i guess i need to let it go. i dont get up with her because i feel as though this is a habit he created with her now. i always got up with the 6yr old but never like this...thanks again! i know i have some valid points on this!

Featured Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

K.B.

answers from Philadelphia on

Holy cow! 19 months and doesn't sleep through the night yet? You poor thing! I'd taser my husband every time he got up out of bed at night. Seriously. That's ridiculous. Is it that he's that concerned about her or that he just wants to shut her up quickly so he can go back to sleep? Can you imagine how much sleep you guys would have gotten if she was allowed to learn to sleep through the night a year and a half ago? I would put my foot down and tell him enough is enough. If he can't handle it he can sleep on the couch so he can't hear her or sleep at a friends house for a weekend while you start the new routine.

K. B
mom to 5 including triplets

More Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

J.L.

answers from St. Cloud on

She's got daddy wrapped around her finger!! I'd ask what'll happen down the road when she wants something from him. Because catering to kids isn't going to lead to a good place. There is absolutely no reason she shouldn't be sleeping through the night and self soothing if she does wake. I'd also want to know why he thinks this is good for her. Who knows, maybe he didn't get enough attention as a child and thinks this is benefiting her. You'll have to find a way to get him on your side, otherwise she's going to keep doing this. Maybe research facts will help??

2 moms found this helpful

F.M.

answers from San Antonio on

Wha? Your husband is rocking the 19 month old back to sleep? Sounds insane! For one, my husband never got up and still hasn't ever gotten up in the middle of the night to care for our kiddo - that was my job. Two, she's 19 months old and should by now sleep thru the night - yes she needs to cry for a couple minutes and self-soothe and fall back asleep on her own! Wow - she's not even given the opportunity to try to self-soothe. Your husband is wrong. You are right - and your daughter is very capable of falling back asleep by evidence of your naptime routine. I don't know how to make your husband learn that he is in NO WAY HELPING your daughter by giving her such crutches (rocking, daddy coming). Print 100+ pages and highlight all the evidence that shows that children need to learn to fall back asleep on their own?? What does his mom say? Sometimes my husband will listen to it coming from his mom. Or maybe your husband needs to go out of town with his buddies. On those nights, you can let her cry it out and train herself to fall back asleep.

2 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

G.B.

answers from Oklahoma City on

This may be the only time he feels like he is getting to bond with her. It sounds like he is hands on and ready to do this. I would let him. It's not hurting anyone or anything.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

S.H.

answers from Honolulu on

Sometimes, babies/young children, are different at night, versus at daytime napping.

Some kids, do self-soothe, some do not until older.
Both my kids napped well, but at night kids/babies can be different. It is a different time of day, there is also the "witching hour" etc. and also, "night terrors" starts to occur, even from 1 year old etc. Night Terrors are developmental based. It is not the same as a baby just waking. You can look it up online. Some kids get night terrors at a later age. Mine got it from about 1 year old.

Many things can wake a child at night. At this age, it is very common that they may wake. Also their REM cycles are changing too as well as their cognition too. Or they get hungry. And some kids, like my daughter, was very sensitive to external stimuli... she'd wake, even if a toilet flushed down the hall. And no self-soothing, would soothe her. Things like that, just woke her. Kids react to wakings or things waking them, differently.

Your Husband, is good about helping his baby at night. MANY Husbands wouldn't even do that.
Many Husbands, don't even do "night duty." At, all.
Its nice, he is attentive and cares.
I have 2 kids, and my Husband never did night duty. This is not uncommon.

Your daughter is young. Some say just do the cry it out.
Some say don't.
Some say that biologically, a child will, at an older age, just naturally start to sleep for longer intervals and self-soothe. Which is my case. That is what I did with both my kids as babies. But that is just me. My son, WOULD self soothe readily. My daughter, would not. She was very sensory sensitive. And for BOTH my kids, how they napped/slept during the daytime... was much different, than going to bed, at night-time. Many kids/babies are this way.

Some kids, will not cry it out. Meaning, they WILL cry... and cry and cry and cry and not stop, no matter how LONG the parent has them cry.
Some kids, will after 5 minutes of crying, just fall asleep. But they do this mostly because, they tire themselves out crying so much.

My son learned to self-soothe on his own.
My daughter, was much harder, at night, to sleep.
Both my kids woke a lot. But both had different proclivities and cues/sounds which I knew very well, and that determined whether I went in there or not, to check on them when they woke.

A baby's sleep patterns, are also never the "best" for the parent. Because, babies/young children, simply wake. It can be due to developmental based changes or teething or many other things. And a parent does not go through this, per their own sleep patterns. But a child does. So a baby's/young child's sleep patterns/awakenings are never copasetic for an adult.

I don't know, if that were me, I'd be glad my Husband was doing the night duty. Or you can wait until she is older, to see if she matures in development to then sleep for longer periods or by pass teething wakings etc. Then see, if she self-soothes on her own, naturally.

Does she have a Lovey to sleep with? Or anything cozy to sleep with?
Both my kids, LOVED that and still do.

OR tell your Husband... that NOT ALL BABY NOISES means that he has to go in there!
Really.
He needs to KNOW her sounds.... and HE may be the one waking her, by going in there for every little darn noise she makes.
Unless she is screaming crying... there is no urgent need to go in there. She might fall back asleep in a couple of minutes.
Babies... routinely make noises, during sleep.
Just like an adult.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

S.H.

answers from Dallas on

If your husband is the one getting up with her then I do not see the problem. Each baby is different and will learn at their own pace and not ours. your baby spent over 9 months inside your belly and felt safe and loved. You can not expect then to just sleep and not need you once they get out. Your little one needs to know that you are there day or night. Nap time is different then sleep time. Soon SHe will be all grown up and you will miss that time.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

K.P.

answers from New York on

I would ask him "why" he goes in so quickly. If this is his way of being "daddy the hero", then help him find another way to be that guy! At this age, she really should be able to sleep through the night and put herself back to sleep if she happens to wake up.

This has become their "pattern" and it's going to be difficult to break it. I would suggest getting the Ferber book from the library. Read it together and talk about how there is a method and a purpose and a benefit. You ALL need your sleep and your husband can't rock her to sleep forever.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

K.L.

answers from Erie on

You don't need baby advice, you need husband advice ;) I'm guessing that daddy loves his cuddle time with your little angel and she loves it, too. I would be frustrated with it, too, if I was being wakened each time. I guess the big question is whether it's just once a night or many times.

If it's just once a night, then she has learned self-sooth strategies (kudos to your nap time ritual). Most babies - and us, too - wake several times a night but learn to fall back asleep on our own. She is probably doing that a few times each night but also lookin' for some "daddy love" too...

If it's many times a night, he needs to be stopped. As others have written, ask him why he's doing it. Based on his response, see if you an reach a compromise... maybe let him cuddle her to sleep at bedtime if he'll let her tough it out in the middle of the night (or whatever works for the three of you).

Good luck... and sweet dreams ;)

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

E.H.

answers from Washington DC on

I also think it is wonderful that your husband is so willing to get up with your daughter. If you really want to try something maybe have your husband wait 5 minutes before getting her. That's about how long mine usually take to get settled back down. Maybe he'll take to it, if he doesn't like it then why not let him have this time with her. She will eventually sleep throught the night consistently. I have 4 and I nursed them all to sleep for every nap and bedtime until they stopped nursing on their own and they all slept through the night between 18 and 24 months some even sooner. So don't worry he won't be rocking her to sleep when she's 10-although he may want to:) Good luck!

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions