Great post! And we have a Monroe as well. :)
We like traditional names with traditional spellings. We also have a very common last name and there were certain names we had to stay away from (historical figures and actors).
I was single when my oldest was born. He is Noah David. He was Max Robert until he was born, after my two deceased granddads. But when he was born he was not a Max! I settled on Noah from my long list but I was torn between the middle names; I thought I may not have any other kids and which grandpa would I honor? My aunt suggested David which is my dad's name. I thought they sounded great together. Ten years later, he is SUCH a Noah. Were he a girl, he would have most likely been Grace Carlisle.
Wyatt Anderson is two. Anderson is an old family name on my husband's side we both really liked. We had known one other Wyatt and that and Henry were the only boy names my hubby and I could agree on. We still like it. Caroline, Hazel and Gretchen were on the list for girl names.
Henry Monroe is four months old. Clearly we didn't find any other boy names to agree on in those two years! We had a list of old family middle names but couldn't agree on any. Henry is also a family name, so we wanted something original for the middle. We were getting heat from the nurses for a name when I threw out Monroe, a name I'd always liked from a book. Hubby loved it and it was decided. Hazel and Gretchen were still our girl favorites.
Each boy has an original name and a family name. And all five of us have names that start with different letters, something I had kinda wanted. They were also all named as the last thing I did before being discharged from the hospital!!