Sister Living with Us

Updated on April 10, 2010
T.H. asks from North Las Vegas, NV
9 answers

I would appreciate any input as to how I can deal with my sister and her 2 teenage daughters living with us. I would also appreciate any feedback on whether I am wrong to feel the way I do. 5 months ago, my sister called me from Florida asking if she could come and stay with us until she could find a job and get a place of her own here in Las Vegas. She is in the process of divorcing her husband and is starting over completley from scratch. Her financial situation is a total mess as well as her personal life. My husband and I did not hesitate for a second to say yes and gladly opened our home and lives to them. We have been frugal our entire lives, saving and spending wisely. We are currently financially stable (although far from well off) and didn't get caught up in the housing market crunch, don't live beyond our means or ask for help from anyone. We make many sacrifices to live a humble and stressfree life. In my earlier years before I married my current husband, I lived below poverty level, and my chuldren and I made countless sacrifices to make ends meet without asking for help. Although I did it on my own and have encouraged my sister to start making decisions on her own. I still have no problem helping her out. My husband and I enjoy helping others and do so very generously and anonymously quite oftten. My sister accurately predicted that if they stayed too long, she was afraid it may damage our close relationship and promised that it would be no more than 2-3 months. When they moved in, I asked if we could set some ground rules and she asked that I not do that to the girls because they had been through too much. Thinking that my love for my sister and nieces would far exceed any inconveniences, I agreed to wait. No rules had been set up until yesterday when my husband and I couldn't take it any longer. We have an entire upstairs that we have converted for them into their own little mini apartment so to speak (minus a kitchen of course). In doing so, we cannot have out of town guests because we no longer have a spare bedroom. Twice in the past month, my husband's family have come to visit and my husband and I ended up sleeping on an air mattress in the living room, as we gave up our bedroom to his parents for 9 days and his brother and wife for 3. One of the rooms we converted had been an antique hobby room for my husband that he is missing terribly as well as space in his garage to build as he loves to do. Just last week, she finally moved most of the boxes from our garage so he can have space to work and build out there. But not before we had to break down and spelll it out for her how inconvenient it was. We had told her in the beginning, the boxes in the garage had to be temporary. The many other things that have surfaced in 5 months are too many to name, but they are all petty if looked upon as any one individual act or occurance. A few examples are, letting their rooms and bathroom get really, really dirty. Wet towels on wood flooring, dirty laundry piling up and smelling , expecting us to cook for them, not heliping around house, not asking if they can do anything for us, or respecting our requests not to argue loudly in front of us, it makes us uncomfortable. It is the compilation of this and much more, and the build up of emotions, disrepect and selfishness that my husband feel has occured that has caused us to start feeling bad about ourselves. We have always considered ourselves good people with kind and generous herrts. We now feel ourselves not wanting to do anymore for them, although we will continue to do so resentfully, because they have no where else to turn. It has turned us into people we don't like being right now. We don't charge them a penny, and watch them spend money on things that we don't even do for ourslves. In the beginning, we whole heartedly bought them things, tried to make them comfortable, did everything they asked of us and more. In my sister's defense, with the economy as it is, it took her 3 months to find a job which none of us anticipated. I cried with her, supported and encouraged her through tihs time. Now, with her savings that she had and her income coming in steady, she needs to find a place, but is hitting brick walls with her credit being so badly. We refuse to put our name on anything for her, it is where we draw the line, because her soon to be ex is still tied in with her and they have a very shady financial past, criminal records and behind 8 years on taxes. Her niece (on her exes side) lives her as well and has offered to put them up for a while if she can't or isn;t willing to move out. we are more than ready for this, but they are reluctant to do that because it is a smaller place and further from their work and schools. we just need a break and i asked her to make a decision by 2 weeks. Am I wrong for this? She is also upset because she wants me to meet her for lunch on occasion, sit and talk at night and be as close as we used to be. I just need some space and I feel everything will be okay eventually, but she is extremely hurt and is trying to make me feel bad for feeling this way. She doesn't feel I should need any space to get over any of this. I just can't pretend everything is the same as it used to be just because we aired a few things out last night. My husband and I have a very strong marriage and will be fine, but it is causing us to bicker and pick at each other. I am starting to resent her for this too, because he is so unhappy at all the sacrifices he has made. Please tell me if I am being insensitive and should keep giving and giving without feeling like anything is being returned. She says they appreciate everything, but their actions don't match their words. Any advice or opinions are appreciated. Sorry this is so long.

1 mom found this helpful

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

More Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

A.S.

answers from Boca Raton on

You and your husband were wonderful to extend the hospitality you did. Stop beating yourself up.

She has repaid your kindness with a complete disregard for your feelings in the matter.

I would be MORTIFIED if I did this to either of my sisters. I would almost prefer to live in a shelter with my children than pull that sort of stunt. If I did have to live with family I would bend over BACKWARDS to pull my own weight and theirs too if possible.

Don't blame all her problems on her husband either. She was right there with him, making bad decisions. She sounds like a self-centered person. Just because she's your sister doesn't mean she thinks like you.

Good luck to you guys - hope you can get your privacy and your life back soon.

JMO . . .

PS: YES! Let her move out!! Let her figure out how to manage her own life! Maybe if she's a bit more uncomfortable in smaller "digs" she'll be more motivated.

5 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

L.K.

answers from Chicago on

Please don't feel guilty. You and your husband have been nothing but kind . Even family can take advantage you and they have done so. Be firm but polite and stick to your guns. You don't owe them anything else. You have done a selfless thing by letting them stay but enough is enough. They need to do for themselves. Eventually they will appreciate what you have already done for them and if they don't ,don't worry about it. You and your hubby need your lives back . Don't let them take away what you have worked so hard for. Take care:)

2 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

A.B.

answers from New York on

Sounds like she doesn't want to leave because of the lovely FREE accommodations you and your hubs have provided. She shouldn't be in the place to make a decision in 2 weeks to move. You should tell her you and your hubby will be happy to help her move in 2 weeks. If her feelings are hurt remind her that she called it early on that if she stayed past a certain time it was going to cause strain. Tell her you will always be there for her emotionally but you need your house back, period. I agree with one post about why it should it be hard with bad credit to find a place. There is definity weekly rental places and as long as she shows good faith and a pay stub she should be fine. Why don't you call a few places in her price range and make some inquiries, otherwise get her packed off to the people who offered. She should consider herself lucky that she had you to help these 5 months and now someone else is offering. You are not wrong. Good luck

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

J.W.

answers from Boston on

I agree with all the previous posts. You have been completely supportive to your sister but the time has come (it came a couple of months ago) for her to move out and make things work on her own. She is going to look for all kinds of excuses to not move out, so be prepared. Let her move in with that other person, and like someone else said, it will be smaller and not as comfortable which is good because it may motivate her to get on her own two feet. It's way too comfortable with you and she is in no hurry to leave.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

L.N.

answers from New York on

i have to say, you have to ask her to leave. she's been living with you for five months. how long is enough, or how long is too long? i say it's too long when it starts taking a toll on you. it is taking a toll on you. you will be blamed for a while, but you cannot avoid that. she needs to go.
good luck

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

P.G.

answers from Dallas on

Your feelings are completely valid. As to the finding a place to stay, if she isn't willing to move in with family, she should check out Craigslist. She may be able to find something month to month since her credit isn't good. It's time for her to start making her own life. I hope that helps.

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

J.L.

answers from San Diego on

Your first mistake was allowing her to talk you into no ground rules. Its like saying, don't set any boundaries. If the kids have been through a lot, guidance and limit setting is exactly what they need, crave even. The fact that you have not shared your concerns with your sister is a testament to a false closeness and one sided relationship. Relationships are a two way street. If you are not sharing your feelings with her, how close are you really? She is allowed to be upset for you not doing what she wants, just as you are allowed to set limits. Again, she may not like it, and her response is her responsibility. Why are you doubting yourself and ignoring what you need? Why is she more important that you? You've given her NO impetus to leave. I wouldn't leave either. She will not read your mind. Resentment begins when you stop stating your truth. You love your sister and you want to see her succeed. You are not helping her succeed. Your generosity is now crippling her. If you approach her stating you hold yourself responsible, this may ease the sting of asking her to leave. I know this was harsh, but thought I'd play devil's advocate w/ regard to who may be responsible for this predicament.

Jen

1 mom found this helpful

S..

answers from Washington DC on

She really needs your help and support right now. I am sure that she is having a rough time right now.

Know that this is not easy for her as well. I bet that she wishes that she had plenty of money to get her own place and to not put you and your husband out.

I wish you all the best and God bless.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

S.H.

answers from Honolulu on

She needs to get out. Of your house.
Period.

You might also try the YWCA... some of them have shelters and transitional housing. Send her there.
If there is one in your area.

Or, here is a link for transitional housing in Nevada:
http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&client=firefox-a&a...=

all the best,
Susan

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions