C.W.
TWO AMAZING POTTY TRAINING STORIES
#1 The Medical Experts'Advice: My son was 4 and still not pt'ed! A friend in a similar predicament went to UCSF experts. They recommended this, and I presented it to my son as follows: "Would you like to see how you can't go down the toilet?" he looked curious and said yes. I took him to the (clean) toilet and asked him to put his foot in it, as far as he could put it. He did. Then I asked him to flush the toilet. He did. He looked up at me with a SMILING FACE OF TOTAL REVELATION. He was out of diapers, day and night, within a week.
#2 The Waldorf Educator's Advice: This worked on my daughter, who was 3 and not yet pt'ed. The Waldorf Preschool would only take potty trained kids in September, and it was July, so I was concerned. She gave me a "Curative Story" for her: to tell a maturational tale, of a little kitten who first slept next to its mama, and wet anywhere, but then learned to go over to the kitty litter box and pee there, and have a nice dry bed... and eventually goes outside and learns to climb a tree... you get the idea. Each episode could progress a little further. I was to tell it every night at bedtime for 2 weeks, and to keep it "sleepy" (don't draw parallels between her and the kitty, that happens unconsciously.) I barely needed to tell it.... I told it twice and my daughter was out of diapers...magic!
The teacher (Shana Rader) also gave me an idea for a story to get her to give up the pacifier, and that worked like a charm also! That's part of what got us into Waldorf education, an amazing and wonderful path with a lot of wisdom in it.
I'd try the story option first, and then the other. PS my son did not know (consciously) that he was afraid of the toilet, but indeed he was.