M.D.
Hi M.,
This is my perception. The only one who truely knows is your daughter. But she may not be able to put into words what the problem is because she didn't have the age and experience to be able to label what the problem was, so even at this age she may still not be able to say what the problem is. What I wrote below will sound harsh, but I think it is what your daughter experienced.
First my story: My father brought me with him when he went to talk to a priest about his unhappiness in his marriage. I was young and oblivious to his discontent. Hearing what he was saying in the next room made me horribly upset. I thought my parents were going to get a divorce. I was quite distraught, asked if I could go sit and wait for him in the car, and went to the car to cry. When my father came out, I asked him if they were going to get a divorce. He said, "No." But that ruined my sense that all was well in the world. My mother would also complain out loud about things my father would do that bothered her when he wasn't around. It made me think of what kind of person I didn't want to marry. I ended up not wanting to marry someone like my father. I didn't want to be like my mother. I do not have a warm, fuzzy relationship with my parents like what is portrayed on tv - I'm not "Daddy's Little Girl." I am angry that they continue their problems and continue to complain about each other in their own ways.
I feel really bad for your daughter. It sounds like she was pretty well traumatized by the divorce and especially the custody battle. It seems she doesn't trust others to be there for her, so she's not there for anyone else. I think she may have felt like a pawn during the custody battle, since you say there was a lot of fighting and it was a nasty battle over her custody. I wonder if you used that word in front of her, "custody." Who gets to keep her. I think it probably made her feel like an object, not a little girl with feelings. Her two parents that originally loved her and gave her a sense of security, became two enemies who did not show respect to each other, or for her. Her happy world of trust and love came crashing down. I think she now is not able to trust others because the two people that she trusted turned on each other and used her as the object of their fight. I am guessing this fight was done in front of her where she could hear. She was treated like a pawn, so now she treats others as paawns. You used her, she is now using you.
I think your daughter is in a lot of pain. She definitely needs to have someone to talk to. I think you and your ex-husband need to go with her and let her know how sorry you are for the way you behaved during the custody fight. You should tell her how you should have behaved. You should tell her how much you love her and how awful you feel for hurting her, that you didn't mean to hurt her. That you were experiencing your own pain during the divorce and that you didn't recognize that your behavior was hurting her. I'm very glad for you and your ex that you are getting along now. Let her know that the two of you are working on getting along better. You made your mistakes and you are now tring to rectify them. The most important problem though is that you think you've hurt her and you want to try to help her feel better and let her know that she is loved and cared for. Let her know that when mistakes are made, a person needs to own up to their mistakes, apologize, and try to rectify them as best they can.
I'm thinking a possible outcome may be that she might try to use your sorrow as a way of getting things from you. Such as you hurt me, so I'll feel better if you give me an ipod, or some other thing. Things won't help, and that kind of behavior isn't good. Your love can't be bought and she won't love you for it. That would be using you, so watch out for it.
Don't expect her to recover overnight. If she does try to trust you again, it's going to take a long time.
I hope the best for you, M., and all involved. My heart goes out to you. I hope all will be healed.
Hugs,
MD