oooooo I feel your stress! children do not come with directions. nor do parents come with the proper tools in how to deal with every little situation we encounter. Unfortunately no two children are alike in how a problem can be resolved. All you can do is find what works for you and your daughter. Yes being consistent in your words, actions and discipling ways does help but of course, not always.
My son is a very strong minded, stubborn, sinister child.....the typical discipline methods do NOT work on him. When he has his mind set on something, the ignore and walk away does not even phase him. On some days yes, whos dealing with him (me or nonnie) and what his mood is like.
We battle, we butt heads, he hits, we scream, we shout, we laugh....we share the outbursts together. Sometimes its a matter of MOM taking a time out. Let me tell you, my son has been saved many times by mom having to take a time out herself. Leaving the room to gather my thoughts and regain my composure helps tremendously, as loosing your cool is VERY easy to do. Even with the most patient parents, they loose it too.
Stick to your guns with your daughter. She needs to understand and I am sure she does, that her behaviour in her outbursts are unacceptable. You will NOT be treated this way and if she wishes for you to meet her needs then she needs to use her words and communicate with polite respectful words. Basically u tell her, that is not acceptable and I will not help you until you can speak to me in the proper tone and use the proper words. Then walk away! while your biting your tongue, lol.
If you do yell at her, set an example, apologize for your outburst. That was unacceptable of you to do that. You realize you were in the wrong and will try harder next time to not yell at her. Then continue with her punishment. It shows you acknowledged your behavior and it was wrong, you apologized for your bad behavior and you followed through with your words of what her punishment is.
I have drilled into my sons head to apologize when someone yells at him for doing something wrong. He understands the emotion behind someones anger and disappointment. Most times he catches ppl off guard by him apologizing for what he did (and hes only 2), that they do not even know how to reply or just laugh with amazment.
The other thing I taught my son was to shake it off. Take a deep breath. Until he calms down, then will I meet his needs, if I am asked properly with respect in a polite manner. If he continues, I keep telling him to calm down, shake it off and take a deep breath. For a while there, my son realized he was over reacting and would do these steps without me ever telling him. He then would proceed to communicate to me in the proper manner and got his needs met immediately afterwards. Then I praised him for controlling the situation and finding a solution to make himself calm and happy again. Give him a high five, hug and a kiss. He gets the biggest smile out of this.
Then you have to think OUTSIDE of the box. The next time your daughter blows off steam. Tell her she needs a mental time out. Not a regular time out, but a mental time out. She just needs to leave the room and when she feels she is ready to try it again, she can come back. Or you leave the room, grab a pillow and give it to your daughter and tell her to scream in the pillow. When shes ready to speak with you nicely is when she is ready to try again.
Ignore can work. Or you give her the oatmeal, she throws a fit, and you just tell her, this is the choice you made, I am not a restaurant. If you want something other then what I made for you, get it yourself. Otherwise this is what you asked for, this is what I made for you. Leave it for her to make the choice. If she does want something else, then let HER get it. If it becomes a pattern, stick to your guns about not offering her something else. Again, mention, your not a restaurant, I do not offer a menu, you have two choices to choose from. Its YOUR decision to choose what you want out of these choices being offered. If you do not like either one. Then you do not eat.
I rather go hungry then eat something I truly do not want. One missed meal won't hurt your daughter. If the next outburst is about food obviously. Again, you got to find something that works for you both. One day it may work, the next episode it may not but yes, do stay consistent. The minute they got your number...u have to start ALL over again.
My son lashes out during nap times. Its a 2hr battle sometimes. One method will work one day, the very next day its a total bust. Its not easy and it def sucks booty. But children have to learn they will not ALWAYS get what they want. They have to compromise and work together to make both ppl happy. Thats life....regardless of their age.
Good luck and hope my advise helps a little bit :)