Experience with Paternity Testing for an Older Child Questioning Paternity?

Updated on February 28, 2012
J.B. asks from Boston, MA
6 answers

Have any of you had any experiences with paternity testing for an older child (teenager)? Can you share your experience and anything you learned from it/would warn others about?

My SD is 14 and has commented in the past that it's weird that she doesn't look like either parent (which is true - she a button-nosed adorable blond and they both have strong noses and very dark brown hair) but last night I guess she came right out and asked my husband in such a direct way that he said that if she's really doubting things, they can do a DNA test and find out for sure. He also said that other than the obvious lack of physical resemblance he has no reason to think that he's not her biological dad but that even if he weren't, the laws of our state would mean that the legal status of their father-child relationship wouldn't change and both would still have all the same rights and responsibilities that they have now even if the DNA doesn't match, so it wouldn't change custody or anything (which is true) and she would be as much his daughter then as she is now, he would still love her no matter what, etc. I'd say that the chance of him being her birth father is 50/50. They weren't married and he signed the birth certificate without ever questioning paternity (which was really dumb in hindsight). So he left it for her to decide whether or not she wants to test.

We have a family therapist and will discuss this with him, but if you've been through this, either as a parent, step-parent or child, I'd love to hear about some first-hand experiences. Thanks!

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

So What Happened?

Thank you all for your responses and for sharing your stories. It will be good to have these perspectives in mind when this comes up again, which I'm sure will happen.

More Answers

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

B..

answers from Dallas on

Since she feels she needs the test, I suppose she should take it. It's very good you already have a family therapist to help the situation.

You know, I look NOTHING like my family. I got every single recessive gene. I am petite, blond haired, small nosed,green eyed. Everyone in my family is built large, brown hair, long noses, very tall, brown eyes. Just the exact opposite of me. I am most certainly biologically from my parents. (There was never a question, they have both been faithful spouses.) My husband is 5'9 and had bright blonde hair before he lost it at a really young age, blue eyes. He is built short and stalky. His brother is VERY tall, lanky, dark skinned, long brown curly hair, dark eyes, face looks nothing like his. They are biological. I have known families who have two different races in the parents, and have several children that look like one of the single races. What I'm saying is, children don't always look like parents or siblings. Genes and DNA are complicated and there is decades and decades of people intermixing their DNA. Not everyone can always look alike, it's not possible!!

3 moms found this helpful

C.O.

answers from Washington DC on

I'm sorry - I have not been through this.

I would get the paternity test done. Just so that she can know.

3 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

S.S.

answers from Chicago on

My daughter was 5 when I married my husband. She was not his and we all knew it. although we had been together long enough that she didn't really understand it. When she was a teenager she started to get out of control. She ran away a lot etc so we ended up doing some extreme things. one of them was a long term residential behavior program. during a lot of the counciling it came out that she knew her dad was not her real dad. Her biological dad had checked out very early in her life and said he didn't believe she was his (only one I had slept with ever I was 19) anyway I went on about my business taking care of her and just erased him out of my life. When my daughter was 15 we went to court and a dna test was ordered. by that time he was an adult and ready for a relationship of some sort. they are in contact now although my husband is dad. the test itself was easy. she went to a clinic where she was at in the program, and i had to go here near our home and he went in MN where he lived. no muss no fuss and results were back in about 6 weeks. (those tv things where they get results in about 5 mins are really not real. we had the occasional your not my dad i don't have to listen to you but those were few and far between. not sure if that helped but there it is lol.

2 moms found this helpful

K.M.

answers from Chicago on

I can say that as a child who has quietly questioned paternity to give this to her. She is lost and confused, looking for a place to belong and no matter how "ready" you think you are you never are ready to hear it. Tell her she is brave, you support her and will be there for her no matter the results. Expect her to drift away no matter the answer as she continues the search for herself. Should he not be the bio dad support her in her search for him - he does deserve a chance to know the truth too! I only have not, even at 30 tested because my family has had enough fall out, and I have been the only "glue" I am not ready to possibly dissolve and be the bringer of the heart ache. It is a HUGE thing for her to love herself enough to share this with everyone else - know this is not something she has taken lightly.

2 moms found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

C.W.

answers from Santa Barbara on

Before I attended school I swore I was switched in the hospital: strawberry blonde hair, green eyes, really tall and fair. My parents were dark haired, dark eyes, shorter and crazy. I look nothing like them! It took basic genetics in elementary school for me to understand recessive genes.

If it was a 50/50 chance and she has asked for a DNA test, I would do it for her. He needs to make her feel secure and loved or there's a chance she can can rebel.

My daughter is adopted and my sister is her biological mother. We couldn't care if she came from Mars or the zoo...she is our daughter. People always thought I was the nanny but we don't care. She has my reddish highlights naturally in her dark brown hair and thinks that's pretty cool.

Good luck!

1 mom found this helpful
Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

H.M.

answers from Dallas on

My son was 10 months old when I met my husband and 2 1/2 when we got married and 5 1/2 when my husband adopted him. He knows he's adopted and we celebrate it every year. He is now 13 and never really asked questions to me. He did when he was little to my mom who could not answer any quesions. When he was born I was pretty sure I knew who the bio was but now that he's older I think I was wrong. I honestly dread the day he comes and asks me cause I know I need to be honest with him. Someone did ask him a few months back infront of me if he ever wondered about him and he said no. And they asked if it was because my husband is his dad and he said yes.
If she is that couisous I would say go ahead and do it.

Good luck and God Bless!

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions