I totally feel for you. That's got to be NOT fun at all!
A few questions come to mind. How long have you been married and how many little ones do you have in the house? Is this the first marriage for one or both of you? Plus, how long since he returned from the military? Those ALL could be factors.
If I read your snippets correctly, from other Mamasource responses of yours, you have 2 step-kids and 3 of your own (I'm guessing with him). If so, you folks have a lot on your plates just with your family. Do you know anything about how his first marriage broke up? Is there any chance he's scared your marriage is on the rocks, especially if you're having arguments about spending time together?
I'm 51, married for almost 19 years to a man I've known for 32 years. We love each other dearly, but it hasn't been easy. We've had our ups and our downs throughout the years. We dated for 5 years, were apart for 7 years, then reconnected and married a year later. Sometimes I need more from him than he can give, sometimes the situation reverses. But you know what, when I come right down to it, it's been worth the joys and frustrations. I've learned so much throughout the years.
When I think of the rocky spots, one time in particular comes to mind. We'd been married roughly five years about then. I remember getting to the point of thinking about divorce. It wasn't the first time, nor would it be the last. And yet, we actually have a pretty good marriage for all of its bumps along the way. But that night, the topic of divorce finally came out in a LONG discussion/argument.
Truth be told, that was NOT what I wanted. I didn't want a divorce, I wanted a husband. But whenever we talked we bumped into dead-ends. Finally, I'd had enough. I didn't start out the conversation expecting to talk about us and divorce. We were actually talking about a couple who surprised us when he left his wife. They had been in counseling and she thought things were improving. But he had already checked out emotionally. We knew her and we were a bit blindsided by the news.
My husband mentioned how he couldn't believe someone wouldn't see the train wreck coming if they were paying attention. I responded that sometimes I see a train wreck of our own coming and I don't think he is aware of that. And he wasn't. It shook him.
A long conversation ensued till the wee hours of the morning. We both talked about what a divorce would look like for us. What did being a couple mean? What did we hope and dream for as a family? How were we meeting those or not?
It was one of the hardest conversations we have ever had. And it was one of many positive turning points for us. It created its own pain because the big D word was out there in the open. But in the same context, I told him that's NOT what I wanted. It was a scary time. It was full of emotion. But it was also honest and cut through a shell that we were using to protect our feelings.
I say this all, because if your husband has had a marriage that failed before, there may be all sorts of things swirling around in his head. Add PTSD, regardless of it's severity, and that could add another layer. Add kids to the mix (any age) and a couple can be pulled even further apart.
There are times, even in a good marriage, that are rocky. The "normal" versus the "red flag" comes out in the discussions. It sounds like your husband isn't ready to talk. Are you ready to wait for him to be ready?
Neither my husband nor I have PTSD per se, but I've dealt with depression on and off for years and we both have our own dysfunctional tendencies from life. Isn't everyone dysfunctional in one way or another? Truly...if we're honest? One person's dysfunctional is another person's normal sometimes.
I'm not saying you have to wait until he's ready to talk all the time. But do you have any guess what his thinking is? Have you asked? Or has he just heard your side of what you've told him?
Sometimes I think my husband would be happy as a clam being on a deserted island, where he could just read internet news all day. Only part of me is kidding. He's a total news junkie. But truth be told, I suppose I'm a Mamasource junkie. Both are satisfying to us. Both serve as an outlet for us.
Some friend's husbands feel that tinkering is their down time, their own personal time. For some, that's when they work out their thoughts and feelings (some are aware of this, others aren't). For others, that's a total ESCAPE from their thoughts and feelings (some are aware of this as well, others aren't). For even others, it can be both at different times.
I knew I needed more interaction with my husband to feel the relationship was worth it. But it took some getting used to. We had to work at spending time together. It didn't just happen. At first, he was just doing it to appease me after that discussion. Eventually, we learned to like and be natural together again. But it took some work, and didn't always succeed.
It's blurred a bit through the years, but I think the toughest years of our marriage were at 5, 7, 13, and 15. I have no data to say that's normal for many couples. It's just my experience. Those years coincided with our son being roughly 1, 3, 9, and 11. This year, at almost 19 years of marriage and our son at 14, we still can be stinkers to each other. But deep down we're still interested in making it work. (I may eat my words some day, but I don't think so.)
I know it's frustrating to have your husband bark at you when you bring up this subject. See if there is any way you can present it to not put him on the defensive.
After our big D conversation years ago, we took a couples class at a nearby parenting resource center. It was helpful. It helped us both to see the other's point of view more. It wasn't the end-all and be-all, but it did help.
Years later, my individual counselor told me she didn't think she could do anything more for me unless my husband was willing to work on some issues together. She wouldn't be our couples counselor because she felt it would compromise my individual counseling, but she was willing to meet with us a couple times.
We ended up doing couples counseling with someone else in her office. He wasn't thrilled but he did it. In the end, that episode was a total bust. Both of us decided it wasn't helping. Fortunately, we both felt the same way. Although it helped in some small ways, overall it wasn't worth continuing.
A couple years later, we found another person who worked with us much better. In fact, we included our son in part of it because it was more of a family dynamic more than anything that was the challenge. It helped us immensely.
Why am I saying all this? I guess to emphasize the fact that relationships can be many layers. It took lifetimes to build who we are as individuals. And it takes a lifetime to build a family that is independent and interdependent in a way that feeds us and satisfies us.
You never know, you may find out, through a "marriage encounter weekend" or through other avenues, that you both have a lot going well as a couple. But be careful of psychoanalyzing your hubbie too much. Your last few sentences of your "So what happened?" response sound like you're sure you know what healthy communication is. I've been there and done that. Just be open to learning something yourself.
I don't have any answers for you. But asking the right questions can take you to a different spot in life. Hopefully it will be better. But only time and effort will tell the full story...and a lot of patience.
Good luck!