Hi Janine -
I have had acne my entire life. Like you, other people wouldn't say I have had "bad" skin, but it has been a rare occasion that my face has ever been completely clear at one time without any pimples (only for a few years after I did Acutane, which is supposed to cure you forever, but only cured me for 5 years). I've tried many different foundations. I used to be a Mary Kay consultant & used their oil free foundation & loved it. But, it has been discontinued, & the new foundation is very heavy. The best foundation I've tried that has good coverage, feels nice, and heals acne at the same time is Proactive. It is a cream-to-powder finish, and is very pretty. It contains salycilic acid, so works on your acne while also covering it. I can't remember how much it costs, but I loved it. I'm currently using Bare Minerals, which is not oily & doesn't clog pores. I think it is around $30, but I like it because as I've aged, my skin has become very sensitive and doesn't tolerate a lot of products. So, if you're looking for something to cover AND heal, I recommend Proactive. If you want something light that doesn't promote new acne, I recommend the Bare Minerals. I also recommend the Proactive skin care system - especially the toner & healing lotion. It really works! :)
~ E.