Playground Etiquette - Silver Spring,MD

Updated on July 09, 2009
G.S. asks from Portland, OR
7 answers

My toddler is very shy and timid on the playground. For some reason, kids like to touch her face. Unfortunately, she doesn't defend herself. She's gotten poked in the eyes a couple of times and now I think she has a phobia because she will freeze up when a kid approaches her. Same thing happens if kids are running or playing rough around her. If she gets scared, she freezes up and often gets knocked over. Once, when she started crying, the other kid slapped her and when I picked her up, he tried to bite her legs.
I have tried not to be a mom that hovers over my child. But because of these incidents, she will not leave my side to go play or explore when we're in a playground. She's better in a classroom situation (I signed up her for classes to have fun but also for social development reasons) but it is still quite painful to get her to leave my side.
Now, my question is, what is my right as a parent to my child, to block or physically remove another child's hands or body from my child?
I usually try to distract the other child with another toy or tell them no touching the face, etc, but I have found that some kids are just focused on doing what they want to do or will not listen to me as a stranger. Things like that happen when their parent/caregiver are distracted and so most of the time, they didn't see what happened and I get dirty looks when my child starts screaming and I'm either removing her from the scene or blocking the other child's hands. Most parents are understanding when I explain the situation after the fact but I would really like to prevent these incidents in first place.
Also, quite importantly, how can I teach my little girl to defend herself?

2 moms found this helpful

What can I do next?

  • Add yourAnswer own comment
  • Ask your own question Add Question
  • Join the Mamapedia community Mamapedia
  • as inappropriate
  • this with your friends

So What Happened?

Thank you for affirming me! I am constantly by her side but I've been criticized for being too protective and hovering (exact words) when the other moms let their kids run around while I get down and play with her on the playground. She started walking late and someone even said it was because I was too protective of her. People have been telling me to "let go" and "let her learn" but you're right, she's only 2! I need to continue following my instincts and do what I think is right.

More Answers

B.C.

answers from Norfolk on

2 is too young to expect her to go play or explore. You're expecting her to act like she's 7. At 2, when you go to a playground, you get in the sandbox with her and do not leave her side. This is not hovering. Kids at 2 (or 3 or 4 or even 5 for that matter) for the most part do not play well together. You have got to be there to make sure no one throws sand (or mulch) into eyes and to generally ensure everyone plays nice. And, I don't care how old they are, what are these other kids doing touching your girls face? You are in your rights to say loudly and rudely to the other kid(s) "Hey! Knock it off!" and if another parent complains - Good! you got their attention. Your daughter will learn to stand up for herself by learning how to from you.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

H.K.

answers from Washington DC on

Your daughter is only 2! At that age I always stayed with my kids and got down and played with them rather than leaving them to their own devices. Sounds like she has had some nasty experiences at the playgrounds you have gone to. Go with her and make the exploring fun! Through role play and example you will be able to teach her how to have fun on the playground, how to get along with other kids and how to defend herself... (yes you definitely need to defend her from the unwelcome pokers and show her how to define her personal space) she has to learn these things, it's not a gut thing for everyone. I would always point out other children who seemed open to playing together and we would go introduce ourselves and play with them. When she is ready she will start branching off away from you and gravitating towards other kids her age. For now, I would not consider your presence "hovering" ;)

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

A.L.

answers from Washington DC on

I don't mean to be harsh, but of course it is your job to defend your child!!! If you won't stand up for your child, who will? Also, your child learns from you. If you let these kids push your child around then she is going to think that is correct behavior and let it continue. Stand up for your kid. She'll only learn to defend herself if she sees you defending her.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

K.B.

answers from Washington DC on

GS,
THis may be a little late? But wanted you to know my 2 year old has children come up to her face as well; it is so weird...like 3 different times/days at a playground it is always a little boy her age, he will come up real slow, feel her face like he is amazed by her, hug her sometimes falling to the ground losing balance and my girl will cry out of fear because of the grip they get on her she cant get away. I always pretend that I am there to supervise my children and any children interacting with mine since no one else is around as though I was babysitting. :/ Yes whoever is telling you , you are overprotective is missing something; everyone told me that with my first girl as well who is now 4 and doing fine without me "right" there AS closely. You are doing such a good job being there for your girl!

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

A.S.

answers from Norfolk on

Hi - I'm so sorry that your baby girl is going through this already. Being that she's only two and truly still a baby girl I would continue to protect her at all cost. I'm not sure if this is everywhere but first I would try taking her to a different park, maybe one not very busy (the less kids there are the more focused other moms or sitters tend to be on their kids). As far as teaching her to protect herself, I'm not sure how effective it will be this young but I think kids her age learn best through role play. At home play pretend and ask her to react as you would want her to at the playground if someone hurt her, ie. yelling "stop that". If mastered this would surprise the offending child and likely attract his/her parent's attention. As another mom mentioned, I would also join a playgroup for several reasons but primarily so my girl can get to feels safe to play with other kids, besides those in school. Good Luck & God Bless.

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

L.P.

answers from Washington DC on

I really feel for you and your daughter because it reminds me exactly of me with my eldest daughter at that age. She was also very timid and tended to get pushed around when we went places. I also wasn't sure what to do because I didn't feel comfortable with reprimanding someone else's child or approaching someone about their child. Then one day this child pushed my daughter down and as usual I stood not knowing what to do and my daughter looked at me with such a "mommy is she allowed to do this to me?" expression, and that was it! If parents can't watch their children and make sure they play nicely, my daughter certainly wasn't going to suffer for it. Anytime after that if another child was pushing or taking something from my daughter I would be very stern with them and say "No! You may not play like that!" or "Excuse me, she was playing with that, let's give it back to her". If someone doesn't like you speaking to their child like that, well, that can't be helped. You have to think; would you rather have a stranger irritated at you or would you rather have your child know she can rely on you to be there for her and protect her?
My proudest moment came about 2 years later when a boy came up to my daughter and tried to shove her away from a toy she was playing with. She shoved him back out of the way and said "Hey! I was playing with that!" My baby had learned to stick up for herself!

Smallavatar-fefd015f3e6a23a79637b7ec8e9ddaa6

A.B.

answers from Washington DC on

I don't find your actions to be "hovering". You are her mother and she is only 2. Some people might believe she needs experiences like these to toughen up, but I disagree. You have a right to protect your child, but I would hope that if you see a situation escalate, you could circumvent it before another child goes into attack mode. Not sure why this is happening, but I'd be very concerned. Are you a part of a playgroup with two or three children who are repeating this type of behavior or is this happening no matter where you go? Your daughter is at a very important stage in her social development, and unfortunately, she is having some bad experiences and is associating other children with pain. Does she have at least one child she can play with who is not so physical? I might plan a playdate at the park with that friend and her child, which would give her someone else to interact and explore withI like the idea of the class environment. Or, I might try some other positive forms of recreation or another playground where she might meet different children until I have had time to help my baby build up her confidence. But, at this age, a lot of children don't really interact, they do parallel play. They are still learning rules and we're all at different stages of development. Some children are very ego centric and if they want something they demand it or snatch it and will attack. Some aren't too aware of other peers, but will play. Some are very sociable early on, but thrive with older children and not other toddlers. Yes, there are aggressive children, poorly trained or high-strung or bullies, everywhere, but these should be isolated incidents, not such a regular occurrence that she is now terrified of her peers. I'm curious about why it appears kids are going after her? I keep hoping that it's one or two of the same children who happen to be there the same time you are. If this is the case, I then would not feel guilty one bit when the child's parents/caregiver arrive at the scene and I explain that I've had to protect my child from theirs. Most people know that their child is aggressive, so it frustrates me when they unleash that energy onto unsuspecting people without monitoring their child. It happens. You cannot fix their situation, but you can make sure your child is safe, feels she is protected and that she learns that behavior is not tolerated in your family. I wouldn't have one bit of guilt. I think you're doing a great job.

For Updates and Special Promotions
Follow Us

Related Questions