We moved to St. Augustine 18 mos. ago and we love it here! We live on Anastasia Island in a neighborhood called Sea Grove. It's a great neighborhood just 1 mile from the beach and half a mile from the only Starbucks in town! There is a Target, Home Depot, Super Wal-Mart, Marshalls, Chick-Fil-A, etc. about 3 miles from us, on U.S. Hwy 1 in St. Augustine, just over the 312 bridge. The beach is a great little community -- not too small that everyone knows your business, but small enough that you get to know people quickly and see familiar faces at the grocery store in no time at all. Sea Grove is still being built out, and you can get a brand-new house for high 200s to mid 300s. There is a neighborhood pool and basketball court, a library and Smoothie shop right at the entrance to the neighborhood, and the YMCA is just 2 miles away. As for pediatricians, we love Ancient City Pediatrics, on the island off of 312 just before the bridge. There are 3 great preschools that my friends all take their kids to -- Anastasia Baptist which is just up the road, Trinity Episcopal which is in the heart of Old Town St. Augustine, about a 10-min. drive from our neighborhood, and also Memorial Presbyterian Dayschool. The public elementary school district we are in is R.B. Hunt Elementary, which is one of the best schools in Florida! Consistently an A school with tons of parental involvement. My husband and I feel like our kids are getting a private school education in a public school! World Golf Village area also has lots of great neighborhoods and you're closer to Jacksonville, but we opted for being close to the beach and we're so happy with our choice. Good luck!