J.
www.turnertoys.com - made in the USA.
Also, Hearthsong.com, which is not completely USA-made toys, but they do test for safety (and have a lot of nice toys).
www.magiccabin.com. Someone sent me this link as "USA Made," but I can't find that on their website. They do say they have rigorous testing and require the toys they sell to meet various safety certifications.
Fat Brain Toys, which I have bought from before, now has a search that allows you to see products made in the USA: http://www.fatbraintoys.com/specials/made_in_america.cfm?...
Adding to my post after seeing the other response - Melissa & Doug is a great idea, and the original Melissa and Doug live right here in Elmwood Park, so that definitely is shopping local!