C.H.
I love the small craft things at AC Moore; the little projects that come all sold in one kit pretty cheap! They sell tem with an Easter theme or just sometimes a car, truck, snowflake or something like that. I also like the foam shapes (we just did one the other day that is a snowflake) from AC Moore and you can decorate it any way you would like-glitter glue, markers, stickers etc. You can buy so many fun crafts there- my kids love their stuff!
I am not sure how strict you are on plastic toys and media items but Target always has an awesome Easter isle as well. I got my boys the Thomas the train Easter pack; 4 Easter decorated tains! They also had Monster trucks (another fav. here!)
You could also buy them something fun for outside; jump rope, sidewalk chalk, a sand bucket, sun glasses, bubbles etc!
Hope some of my ideas help you or someone else and Happy Easter!!!
C. H.