J.G.
For my sons birthday party of course he turned 3 we made cut outs of spongebob (since that is what his theme was) and colored them, i found a pic on the internet and since i cant draw very well i traced it, anyway we hid them all over the yard and had them find them and then at the end we gave them all a little gift (you might be able to do this with the smaller ones while the older ones do musical chairs), all i did was at walmart in the toy section they have a 88 cent section and bought a few toys from there to give them and put in their gift bags (of course they were all littler around 3-5) but they all loved it, im sure that you might be able to find something for the older ones there as well, you could also go to the 99 cent store, or dollar zone and get some little things for the older girls like bath soaps or things like that, sometimes you can find small baskets with a couple of little things for bath. They also have toys there as well like trucks im not too sure what girl toys they have as we dont have any girls in our family. I hope this helps!!