I went there in 2005 and have many friends who have recently used them. I love the clinic and hear so many positives about the staff. The one doctor I've heard more complaints about is Dickerson. Seems you either love or hate her. Sounds like she can be quite blunt...to the point of rudeness. I saw Dr. Friese and he also delivered my son. He is very intelligent and professional. His calmness was great for me. He can seem pretty serious, but he does have an excellent sense of humor. He will not blab your ear off unless you ask questions. At that point he answers them wonderfully and thoroughly.
I also had briefer experiences with Dr. Schoel and she seemed absolutely great. I also thought Dr. Lindman-Miller was so sweet and empathetic. Dr. Gorneau was very light hearted and a jokester. He was probably a little too much for me...made me freak out a little saying I could have the baby any minute when it was still pretty early. It was my first and I was pretty uptight! But he was really nice and very relaxing to be around.
I know a lot of people who like Dr. Elias. I saw a couple of the Nurse Practitioners and athough they were nice, I'd prefer to primarily see a MD.
I know they say to see as many doctors there as you can, I still prefer to establish a "relationship" with a primary one. I think the follow through is better. They know you! In a normal easy birth you spend such a little amount of time with the doctor anyway, it's not such a big deal.
As for Mercy...I had always heard such great things. I honestly can say I pretty much still cry thinking about my experience there. My primary delivery nurse was great (except she chewed gum the whole time), but pretty much everything else stunk. I was put in the overflow area, which was part of the problem. We filed a complaint and I know that measures were put into place to prevent the problems we had from happening again. But I would hesitate to go there again. I've actually heard recently of more positive experinces at Unity. The only problem is they do not have the level 2 nursery if needed. But then again, look at what happened several weeks ago at Mercy.
I think you can be assured that Women's Health is awesome. Plenty of people have great experiences at Mercy, and I've not heard of any recent problems, so I think you'll be OK. Just speak up for yourself if need be. Good luck!