Jennifer,
I have had Farmers for 10 years since I started driving. My parents 20 years BUUTTTT I was paying $167 a month for full coverage and only 1 accident! (I am 26 and drive a 5yo loan car)
I got quotes from the following for the same EXACT coverage: Progressive, Statefarm, Geico, Nationwide, Fred Loya, Esurance, 21st Insurance, Allstate and who knows how many more.
They all were within $10 of what I had up or down. I wasn't going to change for just $10 a month UNTIL I got a quote from AAA!!!!
I am paying now $92 a month! Same exact coverage!! and I now have their awesome Roadside Assistance (they will bring a battery, tire, gas etc to you) if you drink they will tow you and one other person and your car up to 10 miles if you have had to much to drink. Also if you are in someone else's car and something happens you are covered too! So I am saving $75 a mo that is $900 a year!
I switch my renter's ins for my house to them and pay $7 a mo (farmers $8) but I have $30,000 coverage where farmers was only $10,000. I switch life ins (paid $12.10/mo for $75K with Farmers) and now have $100K with AAA for $11.35.
So for me I am saving between all insurances $921 a year. That is a lot toward student loan payoffs for me!
My mom, dad, brother and two friends have switched and are savings some serious $$$ as well!!
Call Chris Mallon (817/750-1493 - ____@____.com) I am not sure if he can help you in his area but he can refer if not to a local rep. Tell him E. Cronin sent you. Can't hurt to have a free quote!