D.W.
Hello!
I was in the same situation and sooo confused! Even much lauded Britax had a recall around that time.
We ended up buying 2 different versions of the Graco Comfort Sport for the cars. They are convertible car seats, meaning they can be both rear and front facing. They were around $80 each at Target. They are easy to install and to take apart to wash the cover.
We like them a lot and would recommend them to anyone.
D.