A.W.
Hi C.,
My fiance's favorite gift ever is a couple years ago we made him a t-shirt. I bought a nice white t-shirt and some fabric paints. I wrote on the shirt "World's Greatest Daddy" and then my daughter made 2 hand prints and under that I wrote "Down" (World's Greatest Daddy Hands Down). He wore that shirt so much it turned into rags. He now has it folded and put away in a box of keepsakes.
My fiance and daughter both love the beach so this year we are going to take him to the beach and spend the whole day. I'm going to pack a picnic for us- all with food that my daughter and I will prepare together.
Good luck!